January 29, 2009

You Tell Me ...

Are we (by that I mean the US) asking too much that we have the top skaters all the time?

This article was in the Washington Post two days ago and it maked me wonder if is the American public at large or the media itself crying out for a skating star, wait make that a starlet. Judging by the comments left in the Washington Post, most of the public were angry that this article appeared front page and "above the fold" - a sign to me that skating's not very popular right now.

I like seeing any skater - no matter what country they're from - do their best. I think you bloggers out there do too. But tell me what you think .... America's Golden Girl from the public or media? Here's their article:

Where Are the Golden Girls?
Once Dominant in Figure Skating, U.S. Is Facing a Steep Decline

By Amy Shipley
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, January 26, 2009; A01

CLEVELAND, Jan. 25 -- The questions usually begin now, a year out from the Winter Olympics: Which of the United States' top female figure skaters is most likely to win the gold medal?

This year, the question is different: Do the U.S. women have hopes of winning any medal?

The U.S. Figure Skating Championships, which ended here Sunday, offered further evidence that the U.S. women's program is mired in its deepest drought in at least 14 years -- and possibly several decades -- with the Olympics in Vancouver, B.C., just over a year away.

"We just don't have that star," said skating coach Robin Wagner, who led Sarah Hughes to her 2002 Olympic gold medal. "We're so used to having the queen of figure skating in our country."

Figure skating is arguably the most popular of the Winter Olympic sports; certainly it draws the largest television audiences. It usually provides both fans and advertisers with the "face" of the U.S. Winter Olympic team -- think Peggy Fleming, Dorothy Hamill, Kristi Yamaguchi, Nancy Kerrigan and Tara Lipinski. And it gives the United States -- not a power in many winter sports -- a boost in the medal table. In the past three Olympics, American women won five of the nine medals available in the individual event.

This year's U.S. champion is 21-year-old Alissa Czisny, who won the title here Saturday night despite falling on one jump and hitting just three triple jumps rather than the customary five or six in her long program. The other top finishers, silver-medal winner Rachael Flatt, 16, and bronze-medal winner Caroline Zhang, 15, have never won a senior event of any sort.

Among the reasons for the apparent decline, skating insiders say, are the new judging system introduced in 2004 that has shifted the emphasis from artistry to technique; the rise of skating's popularity in Asia since the 1998 Winter Games in Nagano, Japan; and the departures in 2006 of Michelle Kwan and Sasha Cohen, who won 15 Olympic and world championship medals between them.

"It's an extraordinary situation," said 1984 Olympic gold medal winner Scott Hamilton, now a commentator for NBC. "Unusual circumstances are producing extraordinary results."

The world championships in Los Angeles in March will provide a pivotal test for Czisny and Flatt. Should neither finish in the top three, the U.S. women will have failed to win a medal at three straight world championships for the first time since 1964 -- which came after the entire figure skating team had been killed in a plane crash on the way to the 1961 world championships.

Czisny's and Flatt's performances will also determine whether U.S. women are allowed to enter a maximum three skaters in next year's Olympic field. If their combined finish does not equal 13th or better (such as a sixth and seventh place), the United States will only be allowed to send two women to Vancouver. That has happened only once since 1924.

"It's obviously a very critical event for us in terms of who gets to the Olympics," said Wagner, who also coached Cohen, who won a silver medal at the 2006 Games in Turin, Italy. "All of us are keeping our fingers crossed."

In recent years, Japan has made the biggest rise in women's skating, winning seven world championship medals since 2002 after winning just four in the previous 95 years. Shizuka Arakawa won the 2006 Olympic gold; Mao Asada won the 2008 world championship gold; and Miki Ando won it the year before -- when Asada finished second. Meantime, South Korea's Kim Yu-Na has won two straight world championship bronze medals.

"I don't really think it's quite as much that the American ladies are deteriorating as much as other countries have gotten a great deal better," said longtime U.S. coach John Nicks, who has coached Cohen, Fleming and Yamaguchi. "Except from [1992 Olympic silver medal winner] Midori Ito a few years ago, we didn't have any threat in skating from Japan or Asia."

It's not as if the United States isn't producing young stars. At the 2006 world championships, Kimmie Meissner of Bel Air, Md., won the world title at just 16, but she has not excelled in any international events since and pulled out of this year's U.S. championships because of an injury. Last year's surprising U.S. champion, then-14-year-old Mirai Nagasu, blamed changes from puberty and her response in part for her fifth-place finish this year. Rather than casting off as the next great star, she struggled all season.

Some figure skating insiders say the new judging system, which was adopted just before the decline, might be contributing. Because the system emphasizes technique over pure artistry, they say, the United States has lost one of its historically greatest assets in the sport. Also, they say, pre-pubescent skaters who can best execute difficult spins and jumps with their small, lean bodies are best suited to accruing high technical marks.

In the old system, judges gave skaters just two marks on a 6.0 scale immediately after they skated; the new system relies on judges casting element-by-element evaluations of each skater's program that are merged into one final point total.

"In the United States, we have emphasized crowd appeal, the artistic side of it, everybody being unique and having a real sense of showmanship," Hamilton said. "That doesn't seem to be as valued as in the past."

Even so, Wagner and Nicks said they believed a young skater could yet emerge to produce a medal for the United States at the next Games. The first step will be the world championships in March, and with the Olympic slots at stake, the pressure already is on.

Winning a "medal is very important," said Richard Callaghan, who coaches Meissner and once coached Arakawa. "But I think the three spots for the Olympics is equally important. We need to get a force back in there."


Aaron said...

I think not only do we expect too much, this negative attention is counter productive. How does reading this make Alisa Czisny feel better about her skating?

And I totally agree, why do so many writers think that we Americans only like American skaters...I certainly count Yu-Na Kim amongst my favorites?

This really doesn't surprise from the Post which has taken some nasty stabs at skating over the past few months...geesh!

Ice Charades said...

Thanks Aaron for your thoughts! You're right about Alisa - winning US Nationals, any year, any time is an amazing accomplishment. The last time I saw her skate was on the reality show/skating documentary on the WE network (maybe 3 years ago?) which profiled four upandcomers, one being Alisa. I thought that show might have been the kiss of death for all of them, but she went on to win. Well done.

I think the Post like most papers just wants controversy and hype. And probably to bring back Michelle Kwan, because she makes for instant ratings.

Thanks for all of your posts on Nationals - I'd be completely in the dark without them.

Anonymous said...

I think it's the media that needs someone to latch on to for the next big thing.

Anonymous said...

Let's bring back Tonya Harding!

Ice Charades said...

Like it or not, Tonya brought figure skating into the mainstream.

Nancy said...

I think if it was certain Michelle Kwan or Sasha Cohen were coming back, they wouldn't write this article - even though the premise is the same - other nationalities dominate womens' skating right now.

I think the media likes to hang on to a "known" thing.